Why Does My Water Smell Like Rotten Eggs?
Rated 5 stars by Chula Vista neighbors
Water that smells like rotten eggs or sulfur is unpleasant, but in most Chula Vista homes the cause is easy to pin down and fix. The smell comes from hydrogen sulfide gas, and where you notice it tells you almost everything about the source. Here is how to find it and what to do about it.
Step 1: Hot water, cold water, or the drain?
Fill a glass with cold water and step away from the sink to smell it. Then do the same with hot water.
- Only the hot water smells: the source is almost certainly your water heater. This is by far the most common case.
- Both hot and cold smell: the issue is in the water supply or the plumbing itself. This is unusual on city water and worth a call to your water provider.
- The glass of water does not smell, but the sink does: the odor is coming from the drain, not the water. That is a drain or sewer gas issue, covered below.
Why a water heater makes hot water smell like eggs
Tank water heaters contain a metal rod called an anode rod. It is designed to corrode instead of the tank, which is what keeps the tank from rusting through. Many anode rods are made of magnesium. Certain harmless bacteria in the water react with the magnesium and produce hydrogen sulfide, the gas that smells like rotten eggs. Warm water inside the tank, especially if the heater sits unused for a while, such as after a vacation or in a guest bathroom, is the perfect environment.
How to fix it
- Flush the water heater. Draining and flushing the tank removes sediment where bacteria live. With San Diego County's hard water, flushing once a year is good maintenance anyway.
- Replace the anode rod. Switching to an aluminum zinc alloy anode, or a powered anode rod, usually solves the problem for good. Do not simply remove the anode without replacing it. Without one, the tank corrodes quickly and will fail.
- Disinfect the tank if the smell persists after flushing. A plumber can treat the tank to kill the bacteria.
If the hot water is also rusty, or the heater is older, read signs your water heater is about to fail and repair vs. replacement before you invest in it.
If the smell is coming from the drain
A sulfur or sewage smell from a sink, shower or floor drain is usually sewer gas escaping through the plumbing. Common causes:
- A dry P trap. Every drain has a curved trap that holds water to block sewer gas. In a guest bath or a rarely used floor drain, that water evaporates. Run water for 30 seconds to refill it.
- Buildup in the drain. Hair, soap scum and food residue decompose and smell. Cleaning the drain fixes it. See slow and clogged drains.
- A failed toilet wax ring that lets sewer gas into the bathroom.
- A blocked or broken vent, or a damaged sewer line. If the smell is strong, throughout the house, or outside in the yard, read what to do if you smell sewage in your home.
If both hot and cold water smell
On city water, a sulfur smell in both hot and cold water is uncommon. Chula Vista is served by Otay Water District and Sweetwater Authority, and both publish water quality information. If the smell is in all of your water, call your provider and ask whether there is any known issue in your area, and have a plumber check for problems such as a cross connection or a contaminated water softener or filter system.
Is rotten egg smelling water safe?
The low levels of hydrogen sulfide produced in a water heater are a nuisance rather than a health risk, but you should not ignore it. A strong sulfur smell in the air, especially near a gas appliance, can also be mistaken for a natural gas leak, which utilities odorize with a similar smell. If you smell gas near the water heater or stove, leave the house and call your gas utility from outside.
Frequently asked questions
Can I just turn the water heater temperature up to kill the bacteria?
Temporarily raising the temperature can help, but it creates a real scalding risk. It is safer to flush the tank and replace the anode rod.
Will a water softener cause the smell?
Softened water can make the anode reaction worse in some homes. If the smell started after a softener was installed, an anode change usually fixes it.
Get rid of the smell
Coastal Rooter flushes and services water heaters, replaces anode rods, and tracks down drain and sewer odors throughout Chula Vista and San Diego County. See our water heater services, call (760) 893-9152, or request a free estimate. Mention our website for 10% off.
Request a plumbing technician
Tell us what’s going on and we’ll get right back to you. Need help now? Call and a real plumber answers 24/7.
